Travel reviews by Trip Advisor

Trip Advisor Based on 276 traveler reviews
VisitMaryland Logo

Trip Advisor Excellent crab cakes!
Oct 27, 2014 by: Swngdok from Southampton, New Jersey, USA
Whenever I am in Ocean City I try to make a visit to Captain's Galley. Their seafood is excellent. Their crab cakes are full of jumbo lump crab with little filler. Excellent soups as well.

Trip Advisor Never disappoints
Oct 14, 2014 by: Corinne M from Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
My husband and I visited this restaurant on October 7 for dinner. This is one of our usual dining spots whenever we are in Ocean City. We have gone here for years and have never had a bad meal or unpleasant server. This visit I had filet mignon and crab cake and my husband had prime rib. Our meals were prepared perfectly and our server was very attentive. In my opinion they have the absolute best crab cakes anywhere.

Trip Advisor Great service, not so great food.
Oct 05, 2014 by: Chelsey226 from 
My boyfriend and I dined here about a week ago and were very let down with our experience. He got the ribs, which he couldn't eat, they tasted awful and appeared over cooked. I got the crab au gratin which was just gross. There was lots of lump crab meat which was nice but it tasted far from fresh. And the au gratin part looked like cheese wiz. And it was $30! Appeared almost like a crab dip app. Not good. On the bright side, we had an awesome server who was very attentive and understanding. I NEVER write reviews but since this was such a poor expierence I felt the need to.

Trip Advisor Disappointing Experience
Sep 26, 2014 by: Dwight F from Bel Air, Maryland
We ate here with another couple on a Friday night and the only reservations available were for 8:30pm. We showed on time for our reservations and were seated within about ten minutes. It was obvious that the table had just been cleared and it lacked napkins & cutlery. We ordered beverages which came promptly - so far, so good. I ordered Maryland Crab Soup as a starter, but my server forgot the soup and needed a reminder. When the soup arrived the server nearly spilled it on me and there was no spoon. As I finally tasted my first spoonful I noted that the soup appeared to have a ham like base and not the traditional tomato & vegetable stock. It was OK, but lacked the Old Bay zest. My wife and I each order the Rock Fish stuffed with crab imperial. The portions were quite generous, but the fish was over cooked & dry and the crab imperial was salty and more imperial than crab. I finished with desert and coffee, but not my first choice for desert as they were sold out of two of the menu items. Perhaps we just hit this restaurant on an off night, but based on this visit I cannot recommend it.

Trip Advisor Go for the crab cakes.
Sep 23, 2014 by: donalda618 from 
We tried the CG II with friends during our most recent late September week in OC. Between the four of us we sampled different appetizers, salad bar, side dishes, and drinks. All were very good. The unanimous entree of choice was the crab cakes, which is a misnomer as they were, in fact, large rounded mounds of lump crab meat. This is a must destination for crab lovers. Service was very friendly. As the evening was a little chilly, we had an indoor table with a harbor view. Fun to pretend the biggest yacht at the dock is yours. Otherwise the atmosphere is pleasant but not up to the pricepoint. Furnishings are well used and the interior is tan/brown and generally drab. However, conversation and the window view of the boats drew most of our attention. Overall, a little pricey but worth it just for the crab.

Read more reviews on the TripAdvisor page for this restaurant.